Chapter Three – Breaking the rules

 

“How do you like piloting the Valkyrie instead of the Hawk, Lieutenant Foster?”

Caleb Foster looked over his shoulder at the captain. The Valkyrie was on course for Talkha and there was little for him to monitor on the helm controls. “It’s good to pilot something again, Ma’am, but it’s just not the same as flying a ship like the Hawk.”

“So I would imagine, but you do understand why we couldn’t use you as pilot for the Hawk on this mission, do you?”

“Yes, Ma’am. I would do a lot to pilot a fast little ship like the Hawk, but loosing my manhood isn’t even on that list.”

Commander Westmore just snorted, but at the tactical station Lieutenant Alvarez laughed out loud, as did several other members of the Valkyrie’s bridge crew including Caleb Foster himself, even if his laughter came a bit reluctantly.

When the laughter had died down Lieutenant Alvarez addressed Captain Veal. “I know we have our orders, but wouldn’t it be best if we just went in and shut down the Talkhan privateers?”

“I wish we could,” Tarin replied.  Her hand found her neck and kneaded it as she went on: “I despise this thinly veiled piracy as much as you do, but the Federation has no jurisdiction in this region of space. The legality of the Talkhans’ claim may be very much in doubt, but we can’t take any direct action.”

“This sucks,” Lieutenant Foster exclaimed, only to go on in a much more subdued tone. “Sorry, Captain, but it looks to me like we are doing the wrong thing here. Wouldn’t it be best to help the Alekians and move against those... privateers, despite all the legal mumbo-jumbo?”

Tarin Veal looked the young Lieutenant straight in the eye. “I can understand your point of view, but the answer has to be a firm No. We can’t place ourselves above the law, however justified it may seem at a time like this. Expedience may be enough for politicians, but it should never dictate our actions. We are Starfleet officers, sworn to enforce the laws of the Federation and the policies of the duly elected government of the UFP.”

“Even if that works against the UFP’s best interests?” Foster asked carefully.

“Especially then.” Tarin rose from her seat and stepped to the helm station. As she leaned down to Lieutenant Foster she lowered her voice so much that Caleb had to strain his ears to make out her words. “Even someone as cocky as you should realize that without a clear chain of command and due regard for the policies of the UFP we would descend into chaos. Can you imagine each starship CO doing what he or she thinks is right, instead of obeying orders?”

Tarin Veal gave the young Lieutenant no time to reply and moved away from the conn station again. “Commander Westmore, you have the bridge.”

Captain Veal crossed the few meters to her ready room and looked over her shoulder, just  as the door slid aside. “Lieutenant Foster, please join me in my ready room.”

*****

“Why don’t you have a seat.” Tarin motioned towards the couch and the young helmsman took the offered seat, just as the captain settled into the chair behind her desk.

Tarin leaned back and crossed her legs. “I guess you are not satisfied with what I told you on the bridge, are you?”

“I don’t get it, Ma’am. I mean, I can understand what you said about the chain of command and following orders, but doesn’t the commander in the field often have a much better knowledge of the situation than everyone back on Earth who gave those orders?”

“A few times I thought so myself and acted upon it, either following my CO’s decisions or making my own,” Tarin admitted. “I was lucky that each and every time Starfleet decided it had been the right choice and, based on the results we achieved, decided to overlook regulations. What you have to understand is that the line between acceptable departure from protocol and outright mistakes is very thin.”

Captain Veal took her time to gather her thoughts before she went on. “Starfleet had two hundred years to develop protocols that cover every conceivable situation we may encounter. At the same time Starfleet captains are allowed a certain independence in making their own decisions. That is because Starfleet trusts its senior officers to act on their orders as best as they can, even if it may not always be possible to confirm in the field how said orders should be interpreted. It is always a difficult decision, perhaps the most difficult decision a starship captain can face.”

She uncrossed her legs and leaned forward. “You, Lieutenant Foster, are far from being fit to make these decisions yourself.”

“Oh, I never wanted to make decisions like that,” Foster replied. “All I want to be is a pilot, not a commander.”

Lieutenant Foster

“Well, that is too bad.” Tarin sighed. “I was hoping I could trust you with a little more responsibility than just being a helmsman.”

It took Lieutenant Foster a moment to recover his speech. “Ma’am?”

“Mr. Foster, I’ll be frank with you. When you came aboard this ship I had my doubts that you would ever become a respected member of this crew. From what I hear you are sometimes still a bit abrasive with the enlisted crewmembers, but all in all I am impressed by the way you handled yourself during the last two months. What I would like to hear from you, before we discuss anything else, is why this change happened?”

Foster drew a sharp breath and rubbed the bridge of his nose. He had noticed the change in his behavior, but never before tried to put it into words. “Permission to speak freely, Ma’am?”

When Tarin Veal answered with an inviting gesture and a “Go ahead” Caleb Foster slowly started his explanation: “I am good at what I do, really good. Wherever I was posted I was always the best pilot. I know it sounds arrogant, but it’s still true. Being a helmsman is what I have been for years and I guess if I couldn’t make everyone realize how good I am I would have lost some of my self-esteem.”

He rested his arms on his knees and looked down on the deck, drawing another deep breath. “I never cared what everyone thought as long as I could think of myself as the best of the best. When I got posted here I tried the same pattern again and it just didn’t work. I knew that Galaxy-class crews are picked from the very best, but I never expected what I found here.” He raised his head and looked Captain Veal straight in the eyes. “Let’s face it. Kevas did at least as good a job during that simulation as I did and I thought he was just a crewman, a mechanic in way over his head.”

When Tarin heard Foster refer to Reto Kevas by his given name a warm smile crossed her face. “Go on, please.”

“I guess what changed me was the realization that around here I am no longer the top dog, not even as a pilot. I looked up Lieutenant Hagen’s record and I guess she is about as good as I am. Hell, it goes for everyone, not just her. Everyone on this ship can pull more than their own weight.”

“So you thought you had to work even harder to stay on top, but at the same time you knew you could only achieve the recognition you wanted if you became part of the team?”

“I couldn’t have said it any better myself,” Foster replied and grinned.

Tarin softly laughed and rose. Pausing at the replicator she looked over her shoulder at Lieutenant Foster. “Do you think you are ready to prove yourself as part of the team and not just as a pilot?”

*****

The Valkyrie's captain's yacht descended below the clouds and her occupants got their first view of Altassa, capitol of the planet Talkha.

"Looks more modern than I had anticipated," Lieutenant Alvarez remarked.

"These people had two hundred years to make themselves at home here. What did you expect, some rag-tag shantytown, like in a Western holonovel?"

"No, Captain, I have seen enough frontier worlds and colonies to know how unrealistic that would be, but skyscrapers like these I had not expected. After all Talkha is about fifty or sixty years behind the Federation technology-wise."

As Lieutenant Foster turned the yacht into a slow spiraling descent and engaged the autopilot he, like Tarin and Felix Alvarez, studied the city below them. The skyscrapers were truly impressive –fingers of glass and concrete that stretched out to reach for the clouds and the stars beyond. But as impressive as they were they formed only the nucleus of a much larger city. Past the parks that encircled the city center smaller buildings were laid out in a regular pattern of concentric rings, connected to the center by streets arranged like the spokes of a wheel. 'Or rays of a star,' Caleb Foster thought as the bright orange sun of Talkha broke through the cloud cover and rays of light dance across the city.

Outside the ring of residential quarters, at least that's what Cal took them for, six industrial zones were arranged around the city in regular intervals. And industrial zones they were, there was no mistaking that. Smokestacks reached into the sky, belching out clouds and flames. Huge warehouses, cooling towers of power plants, huge pipework running between and through the enormous buildings that had to be factories. As the yacht circled low over the city for the last time before turning on her final landing vector Cal Foster could even see large cranes loading containers on transport vehicles, some wheeled, some hovering half a meter above the streets on cushions of air or electromagnetic force.

Lieutenant Foster switched from his programmed autopilot course to the landing beacon. "We are on final landing approach." He pointed out the cockpit window. "We should touch down right there, at the edge of the city center, beyond that line of trees."

"Very good. You know what to do, Lieutenant Foster?"

"Yes, Ma'am," the pilot replied, anxiety mixing with self-confidence in his voice. "If I get the chance I'll look around, talk to the locals without making it look like a social survey. Don't worry, I can managed that."

*****

When Tarin and her two officer's stepped from the Isis their welcoming group was already waiting at the edge of the landing pad. Two men and two women in brown and gray suits stood in front of a large hovercar, flanked by two men in dark blue uniforms who had their hands close to their holstered guns. A large truck was parked ten meters behind the group and two more guards stood near its rear. In addition to their sidearms both carried rifles slung on their back.

That the guards stayed a few steps behind when the civilians moved forward to great the Starfleet officers did little to make Tarin feel more welcome. From all she had learned about Talkha she doubted that the politicians and diplomats of this strongly regimented world needed so much protection. It seemed paranoid to bring four armed guards to great three unarmed visitors. And for a simple honor-guard it would make little sense to keep half of them in the background and have only some equipped with rifles.

Before Tarin could devote any more thought to it she had reached the four Talkhans who had come to greet them. The older of the two men cleared his throat and extended his hand. "Welcome to Talkha. I am Minister Tretyak."

Tarin shook the hand that was withdrawn at the first opportunity and put up a smile. "Captain Veal of the Federation starship Valkyrie. Thank you for seeing us on such short notice, Minister Tretyak. Allow me to introduce two members of my crew, please. Lieutenant Alvarez, my chief of security and Lieutenant Foster, the Valkyrie’s helmsman."

Tretyak nodded towards both men, before he half turned and gestured towards the hovercar. "If you will come this way, please. My office is only a few minutes away."

"Yes, of course," Tarin replied. "There is just one other thing. A small favor I would like to ask of you if it’s not too much of an inconvenience. Lieutenant Foster has expressed an interest in learning more about your world. Do you think it would it be possible for him to look around your city while we discuss matters of interstellar diplomacy?"

Tretyak thought about it for several seconds before he motioned one of his female associates forward. "That should be possible, but I think it would be best if Ms. Basiri accompanied your Lieutenant to answer any questions he might have."

*****

Before he sat down opposite the Talkhan, Caleb Foster shot a quick glance out the second story window at the yacht, but there was no activity at all on the small landing pad. They had taken a short walk without talking much and Caleb had quickly decided he needed a more comfortable surrounding to get anything from the Talkhan. "So, you are a diplomat."

"No, I am not. I am an executive assistant."

Lexa Doig as Karena Basiri

"I see.” Foster really wanted to scratch his head while he figured out her disapproving attitude, but just folded his hands on the table instead. “So you organize things, keep everything running smoothly at the ministry, that sort of thing?"

"Yes, that is an important part of my duties." Before Karena Basiri could add anything she noticed the waitress who had silently stepped close to their table. "Perhaps you would like something to eat or drink?"

After Foster and Basiri had both ordered coffee and some pie she had recommended the Talkhan picked up the conversation again. "And you are a pilot, as I understand it. That is quite a high ranking profession. How many generations has your family been pilots, if I may ask?"

"Uh, none," Foster carefully replied, the impression that he was treading on thin ice breaking through his rising attention to the Talkhan's beauty. "My father was a history teacher and my mother a painter."

"But, but..." she stared at him in sheer disbelief. "Your father a scholar and you mother an artist, how could you be anything but,..." it took her several seconds to work it out, "a scholar?"

"What has my parents' occupation got to with anything? Don't tell me you only became an assistant because it runs in the family?" Cal Foster was as stunned as the Talkhan.

"Executive assistant," she shot back and Cal replied with a quick "I am sorry. I apologize."

As they noticed the waitress and leaned back to give her room to place cups and plates on the table Foster and the Talkhan both thought about how strange the other was.

*****

They had eaten in complete silence, both hardly looking up from their plates. Caleb finished his pie and downed it with the last of his coffee. The pie had been too sweet for his liking, tasting like a mix of honey and strawberries with a bucket full of sugar thrown into the mix, but at least the coffee was good. Strong, bitter, almost enough to forget the taste of the pie.

"Okay, perhaps we should try a fresh start. Seems our societies are pretty different. Perhaps you could just tell me a little about your world and I'll tell you a bit about mine. Would that be okay with you?"

Karena Basiri took a small sip and eyed the Lieutenant over the rim of her cup. "That may be for the best, but I am not sure I will be able to understand your ways, even if tried."

Caleb slowly nodded and tried to recall his basic social science and diplomacy lessons. "To be honest, I feel the same way, but than again, the Federation is based on the idea of getting along despite all our differences."

The Talkhan still looked troubled, so Foster tried his best to put her at ease: "Why don't you show me around? I can't go too far from the yacht, but seeing your society at work may help me better understand your people."

When they walked through the park near the landing pad a little later, neither Basiri nor Lieutenant Foster had spoken more than a few words. "Tell me a bit more about this city," Caleb took the initiative. "During our landing I could see the industrial zones and I take it between them and here are mostly residential sectors, but what about the city center?"

"What about it?" she cautiously replied.

"Well, what purpose does it serve? I guess it's the seat of your government, but what else? All these skyscrapers can't be just filled with ministries and government offices."

"No, of course not. There are all kinds of businesses here, from shops and restaurants to pretty much else you can imagine. And a lot of people live here too. Many people who run businesses in this part of the city live close to their shops and of course our leaders have residences here."

For a few minutes they walked on in silence again, as Caleb tried to make sense of the Talkhans and their way of life. "And your leaders, your politicians, they have a long family tradition too, I guess."

"Yes. Don't tell me on your homeworld it's any different?"

"Well, actually it's quite different back on Earth," Caleb started and told her about the United Earth Republic. He had become so used to it that at times he had to rack his brain to remember all the details, but in the process he learned a few things about Basiri and her world too. She was quite intelligent, catching every obvious detail he forgot to mention and while she was still baffled by the differences between their cultures she relaxed the more Caleb talked about his world instead of asking about hers.

"But it makes no sense at all," Karena concluded after Cal Foster had finished. "If practically everyone can become a leader among your people there is no way you can be certain they have the skills and knowledge to serve efficiently in their offices."

"No," Caleb agreed, " we can't be certain, but there is a lot of information available to the public, so we can form a pretty good picture of who we are voting for and besides, if someone doesn't fulfill our expectations, we can always vote him out of office at the next elections. But there is something I was wondering about your system here on Talkha."

"What is that?"

"How can you be sure that your politicians don't become complacent? Forgive me if this sounds like a stupid question, but there seems to be no incentive for your leaders to do the best they can. With all the traditions supporting them, their position seems to be assured, even if they don't try their best."

*****

"So you are saying that the system works for two basic reasons. On the one hand family traditions ensure that everyone who takes up a certain job or position has the best training and qualifications for the job."

Basiri replied with a nod and an "Uh-huh", before Foster went on. "On the other hand everyone just knows their place in your society, so they won’t do anything to change the status quo, because everyone is happy doing what they do and it’s what works best anyway?"

"I think you are simplifying our culture too much, but you are more or less correct." They had rounded the landing pad twice by now and Karena Basiri sat down on a bench near the restaurant they had left an hour ago. "What makes your culture look so strange to me is how insecure everyone must feel. You go through all your childhood and adolescence without knowing what your place in life will be. I could never imagine how that feels. Our family traditions don't just give us the best possible preparation for our future duties, but they make sure we all know what our place in our society is."

Lieutenant Foster sat down at the far end of the bench. "So it's all a kind of safety-net."

"No, it is not." Basiri’s earlier resentment resurfaced with a vengeance. "You only need a safety-net when you are insecure or exceed your limits. I have never done that and I have never felt insecure in my whole life. Can you say the same for you?"

Foster drew a long slow breath. "No, I can't." Before the Talkhan had a chance to comment, the human went on: "There were times when I had wished that I had made different choices, done something else with my life, but I don't think that's important."

"Go on." She briefly wondered why she had said it, but she never before had a chance to talk so much to an alien. Foster was a strange man, but at least he was open and direct about it.

"The advantage my culture has, at least I think of it as an advantage, is that we can all do what we want. We make a choice about who and what we want to be. Sometimes we have to strive very hard to realize our ambitions, but that we set our own goals can provide a strong motivation. I don't think I would have become as good a pilot as I am, if I hadn't wanted it so much. We may lack your feeling of security, but we make up for it in determination and motivation."

Karena looked straight across the landing pad as she tried to figure out what Foster had just said. "You think we are complacent, lacking drive to become more than we are?" It was a strange thought, but in a twisted way it seemed to make some sense.

"That's how it looks from where I sit, but I told you that the Federation is all about embracing diversity. There are a lot of different people in Starfleet and the UFP and at times I can’t understand half of them, but I can still work with them." He rested his arm on the backrest of the bench and turned towards her. "You Talkhans are who you are and that's just that."

At that moment Foster's combadge chirped and he was quick to reply. "Lieutenant Foster."

"Lieutenant, this is captain Veal," the reply sounded from the tiny communicator. "We will be arriving at the landing pad in about ten minutes. Please have the Isis stand by for launch."

"Yes, Ma'am," the Lieutenant replied before he tapped his combadge off. "I am afraid we will have to cut our conversation short. Perhaps we can continue another time?"

"Maybe we will, but I don't see why we should. Our cultures are just too different to provide much common ground."

"Perhaps." Foster nodded and started to walk towards the Valkyrie's yacht after a simple "Goodbye then."

He had covered about twenty meters when the Talkhan stopped him with one final question. "Lieutenant Foster, do you think I could get access to your ship's database if I wanted to learn more about your world?"

The human turned around and considered the question carefully. "I don't know. Would be best if you asked the Captain, but I don't see why not." Again he nodded, but this time it was a much more friendly gesture accompanied by a smile.

*****

"How did you like your stay on Talkha, Lieutenant Foster?" Tarin asked as the Isis lifted off and the city of Altassa fell behind.

"I saw little of the city, but it looked like a nice place. The people on the other hand..."

"Go on, Mr. Foster, just tell me what you think about them."

"Well, Ma'am, I think they are pretty strange. That woman I spoke to, Basiri, I think it never occurred to her even once in her life that she could be anything but what her family tradition turned her into. I just don't get it. I mean I can understand that it makes them feel safe and content, but how can that be enough for them?"

"Because they have never known another way of life.” Captain Veal reclined in her seat. She could imagine how hard it was for Lieutenant Foster to comprehend Talkhan society, but a part of her could understand these people only too well. “Think about it, they never had much contact with offworlders, and when they did, their diplomats and traders handled it. Most Talkhans probably never realized that there could be another way of life. And even if they did, it must have looked to them like their own ways were superior to any alternative. Their government works, they are provided for, everyone knows their place in life. Compared to that every other system must look chaotic, full of unnecessary risks and chances."

"Yes, that was the reaction I got from Basiri. It's just hard to understand." Cal Foster looked over his shoulder. "By the way, Basiri asked me if she could get access to our database and I told her to ask you about it. Did she do that?"

"Yes, she did. I asked her to contact us later today, so we can work out what access to grant her, but I am willing to allow her access to all our public files and history database." Tarin raised an eyebrow at Lieutenant Foster's smile. "What do you make of her curiosity?"

"I am not sure. I hope it's something else, but it's possible she just wants to confirm for herself how chaotic our society is. Maybe she just needs to strengthen her own belief in her world’s system by comparing it to our ways."

"An interesting perspective. You know, Lieutenant, we may make a good diplomat of you one day."

*****

"How was your visit with the Talkhans?" Moira O’Shea asked.

"Oh, Minister Tretyak and his people were polite, listened to everything I said, and we got nowhere." Tarin Veal slowly lowered herself into the seat at the head of the conference table, instead of just slumping down like she wanted. "I took great care to explain to the Minister how irritated the Federation is about the measures recently taken against Alekian shipping in this sector. In turn he informed me how much his government regretted any disruption caused to Federation interests, but tried his best to let me know that Talkha would not change its position, without ever directly saying so or indicating why they took this position in the first place." Tarin sighed and brushed a strand of hair from her face. "What was your impression, Lieutenant Alvarez?"

"It's just a gut feeling, but I thought they were pretty nervous, especially Minister Tretyak. Not so much about the Valkyrie, but more about you, Captain. But I could be wrong about that."

"No, I don't think you are," Tarin said. "I have studied the reports from our earlier political contacts with Talkha and I thought Tretyak was a good diplomat, but when I talked to him he appeared quite different. Now that you mention it I can only think of it as a deep-seated mistrust. Be that as it may, I have a com-conference scheduled with Tretyak and the Talkhan minister of commerce early tomorrow morning. Perhaps that will get us somewhere, but not without further information. Commander Westmore?"

"I have little direct information. I gained access to the Talkhan public records easily enough, but all decisions concerning territorial claims or the privateers have been declared secret for reasons of planetary security, so there never was a public vote on them."

"Makes sense I guess. Maybe it was too much to hope for a stroke of luck so early in our investigations."

Alex Westmore smiled one of his rare wry smiles. "There is still a lot to learn from the Talkhan records. At least two thirds of the secret debates during the last six months have been initiated by Bertram Novak, the Talkhan minister of defense. I have the computer working on any correlation between secret debates and publicized events. With some luck we will have a good idea what these decisions lead to by tomorrow morning."

*****

 “Hi darling.” Ben placed a quick kiss on Tarin’s cheek and got out of her way. She was making pancakes and from the looks of it she was prepared to make quite a lot. Sometimes she was cooking because she enjoyed it and sometimes she did it to distract herself, to get her mind off something that troubled or frustrated her. This smelled like the latter, but it also smelled quite good.

"How was your day?" Ben asked as he sat in one of the dining chairs.

"Don't ask. I have no idea where to start negotiating with the Talkhans. As long as I can't figure out what their goals are it will be difficult, perhaps impossible, to strike a deal with them. I just hope Dar and Rishana can provide us with some information that sheds new light on the situation, but I don't expect to hear from them for another two or three days."

"And you think information on the Talkhan's goals is all you need? From the mission briefings it looks like their society itself could provide some serious complications."

"I don't think so. The problem is that the Talkhans simply don't want to negotiate. They listen attentively to all I have to say, graciously nod their heads, agree to my arguments, and then just say no to everything I suggest. They claim it’s all a temporary measure, but never care to explain why or how long it is going to last. But enough of that. How was your day, Ben?"

"Pretty routine. It's time for enlisted performance evaluations again."

"No problems there I trust?"

"Not at all. I am satisfied with everyone's performance and some of those guys are doing an outstanding job." Ben Tucker’s pride in his people was almost tangible, radiated outward and warmed Tarin more than the heat from the stove.

Behind her back, unaware of Tarin’s first genuine smile of the day, Ben continued: "Take PO Reto for example. Maintenance of the Hawk doesn't require much of his time, as we rarely use it. So he helps out where he can and when that doesn't occupy him he studies engineering theory. He does a great job and everyone likes working with him. If he keeps this up we should promote him to Petty Officer Second as soon as possible."

"Let's wait until the next evaluations in two months. If you still feel the same about him then, just run that recommendation through Dar's office to me. It's too early to give him the full promotion to PO2, but I should be able to give him a provisional promotion, if it comes endorsed by my Chief Engineer and XO."

"Sounds like a plan," Ben said through a big grin. "Speaking of plans, have you made any for this evening?"

"I would like to study Talkhan history some more. I know about their relations to their neighbors during the last few years, but it can't hurt to study the history of Talkhan foreign relations in more detail." She looked over her shoulder, an apology on her face, but a trace of her smile still remained around her eyes. "I am sorry, I hope you are not too disappointed."

"No." Ben made a vague gesture, but winked as he went on. "I expected as much. I know how things go once you embark on a new project or mission. Don't worry. Today I'll be content with a home-cooked dinner and a few minutes of your time if you can spare them."

"Don't worry," Tarin replied, a loving smile playing across her face, "you will get both."

 

Prologue    Chapter 1    Chapter 2    Chapter 3    Chapter 4    Chapter 5

Chapter 6    Chapter 7    Chapter 8    Chapter 9    Chapter 10    Chapter 11    Chapter 12

Back to Navigation and Updates